Download PDF Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander
Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander. Accompany us to be participant right here. This is the site that will certainly give you relieve of browsing book Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander to read. This is not as the various other website; the books will be in the types of soft documents. What advantages of you to be participant of this website? Obtain hundred compilations of book connect to download as well as obtain constantly updated book on a daily basis. As one of guides we will offer to you now is the Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander that has a quite satisfied concept.
Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander
Download PDF Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander
New updated! The Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander from the best author and author is now offered right here. This is guide Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander that will certainly make your day checking out comes to be completed. When you are trying to find the published book Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander of this title in the book store, you might not discover it. The troubles can be the limited editions Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander that are given up the book establishment.
When some individuals considering you while checking out Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander, you may really feel so proud. But, as opposed to other individuals feels you need to instil in on your own that you are reading Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander not because of that reasons. Reading this Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander will give you greater than individuals appreciate. It will overview of know greater than the people staring at you. Already, there are many resources to knowing, reviewing a book Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander still becomes the front runner as a wonderful way.
Why need to be reading Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander Once again, it will rely on exactly how you feel and think about it. It is surely that a person of the perk to take when reading this Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander; you can take more lessons straight. Even you have actually not undertaken it in your life; you can get the encounter by reviewing Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander As well as currently, we will certainly introduce you with the online book Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander in this web site.
What sort of publication Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander you will favor to? Now, you will not take the published book. It is your time to obtain soft file publication Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander instead the printed documents. You could enjoy this soft file Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander in at any time you expect. Even it is in expected area as the various other do, you could check out the book Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander in your device. Or if you want much more, you could continue reading your computer system or laptop to get full display leading. Juts find it right here by downloading and install the soft file Surfaces And Essences: Analogy As The Fuel And Fire Of Thinking, By Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander in web link page.
Is there one central mechanism upon which all human thinking rests? Cognitive scientists Douglas Hofstadter and Emmanuel Sander argue that there is. At this core is our incessant proclivity to take what we perceive, to abstract it, and to find resemblances to prior experiences—in other words, our ability to make analogies.
In The Essence of Thought, Hofstadter and Sander show how analogy-making pervades our thought at all levels—indeed, that we make analogies not once a day or once an hour, but many times per second. Thus, analogy is the mechanism that, silently and hidden, chooses our words and phrases for us when we speak, frames how we understand the most banal everyday situation, guides us in unfamiliar situations, and gives rise to great acts of imagination.
We categorize because of analogies that range from simple to subtle, and thus our categories, throughout our lives, expand and grow ever more fluid. Through examples galore and lively prose peppered, needless to say, with analogies large and small, Hofstadter and Sander offer us a new way of thinking about thinking.
- Sales Rank: #304681 in eBooks
- Published on: 2013-04-23
- Released on: 2013-04-23
- Format: Kindle eBook
From Booklist
*Starred Review* In what Einstein cherished as the “happiest thought” of his life, Hofstadter and Sander discern a mental process that empowers the mind not just of the rare genius but also of the ordinary person. That process—the framing of analogies—received favorable attention from Plato and Aristotle, Kant and Nietzsche. But many modern empiricists, including Hobbes and Locke, have warned against analogies as intellectual snares. And many tunnel-visioned students see in analogical thinking only the logic-chopping of an IQ test. Hofstadter and Sander tear through the misperceptions, demonstrating the astonishing conceptual power of analogies—manifest when mathematicians venture from real to imaginary numbers, when physicists leap from photons to vector bosons. That power shows up in unexpectedly ubiquitous, ordinary ways, though, as we meet everyday challenges by categorizing the features of those challenges and by dredging up forgotten but relevant past experiences to interpret them. Surprisingly, only analogies enable us to recognize deep essences behind surface appearances and to weigh competing options in national policy or personal life. Readers do confront the risks of false and stereotypical analogies, but soon realize that analogy-making is the pilot light of creativity—and essential for adapting to a changing world. A revelatory foray into the dynamics of the mind. --Bryce Christensen
Review
Science
“Surfaces and Essences warrants a place alongside G�del, Escher, Bach and major recent treatments of human cognition. Analogy is not the endpoint of understanding, but its indispensable beginning.”
Nature
“Lucid and, page for page, a delight to read.... [Surfaces and Essences contains] gems of insight.”
Wall Street Journal
"Clear, lively, and personal."
Globe and Mail (Canada)
“Knowing what makes a duck a bird and what makes a plane not a bird may not seem like very profound mental feats—but Douglas Hofstadter and Emmanuel Sander see such cognitive connections as part of an extraordinarily profound process.... Be prepared to become hyper-conscious of the myriad of analogies one makes every moment of every day.... The end result is a book that is ambitious and provocative.”
Booklist, starred review
“A revelatory foray into the dynamics of the mind.”
Library Journal
“Like Hofstadter’s Pulitzer Prize-winning Godel, Escher, Bach, this work executes, from a very complex thesis, an understanding by general readers while also appealing to specialists in philosophy of mind and cognitive science.”
Kirkus Reviews, starred review
“How do we know what we know? How do we know at all? With an enjoyable blend of hard science and good storytelling, Hofstadter and French psychologist Sander tackle these most elusive of philosophical matters.... [I]t’s worth sticking with [Hofstadter’s] long argument, full of up-to-date cognitive science and, at the end, a beguiling look at how the theory of relativity owes to analogy.... First rate popular science: difficult but rewarding.”
Melanie Mitchell, Professor of Computer Science, Portland State University, and author of Complexity: A Guided Tour
“Hofstadter and Sander’s book is a wonderful and insightful account of the role of analogy in cognition. Immensely enjoyable, with a plethora of fascinating examples and anecdotes, this book will make you understand your own thought processes in a wholly new way. It’s analogy all the way down!”
Steven Pinker, Harvard College Professor of Psychology, Harvard University, and author of How the Mind Works and The Stuff of Thought
“I am one of those cognitive scientists who believe that analogy is a key to explaining human intelligence. This magnum opus by Douglas Hofstadter, who has reflected on the nature of analogy for decades, and Emmanuel Sander, is a milestone in our understanding of human thought, filled with insights and new ideas.”
Gerald Holton, Professor of Physics and History of Science, Emeritus, Harvard University
“Hofstadter and Sander’s book starts with two audacious goals: to show that none of us can think a minute without using a variety of analogies, and that becoming aware of this fact can help us think more clearly. Then, patiently and with humor, the authors prove their claims across the whole spectrum, from everyday conversation to scientific thought processes, even that of Einstein.”
Nancy J. Nersessian, Professor of Cognitive Science, Georgia Institute of Technology, and author of Creating Scientific Concepts
“Placing analogy at the core of cognition Hofstadter and Sander provide a persuasive answer to the question ‘what is thought?’ Analogy is the mechanism underlying the myriad instances of concept formation and categorization we perform throughout any day, whether unconscious or explicit, without which there would be no thought. They mount a compelling case through analysis of a wealth of insightful—imaginative and real—exemplars, from everyday thinking to the highest achievements of the human mind, which are sure to persuade a broad range of readers.”
Elizabeth F. Loftus, Distinguished Professor, University of California, and author of Eyewitness Testimony
“Surfaces and Essences is a mind-boggling argument for the central role that analogies play in human thought. Hofstadter and Sander’s witty and profound masterpiece will leave you thinking about thinking in totally new ways.”
Donald Norman, author of Living with Complexity and The Design of Everyday Things
“Doug Hofstadter and Emmanuel Sander rip apart everyday understanding to reveal insights of both mind and universe. The key is to recognize that analogies and concepts are the same things, that they are ubiquitous, universal, and key to understanding human thought. Easy to read, but deep to comprehend. The result is both enjoyable and profound.”
Barbara Tversky, Professor Emerita of Psychology, Stanford University, and Professor of Psychology and Education, Columbia Teachers College
“Surfaces and Essences has much of both. And more. This book is fun! And serious. Category, analogy (and similarity) are at the core of cognition. On every page, you will find delights: you will be informed, you will be puzzled; you will agree vehemently and you will disagree just as vehemently; you will ponder. And you will return for more.”
About the Author
Douglas Hofstadter is Distinguished College of Arts and Sciences Professor of Cognitive Science and Comparative Literature at Indiana University. His previous books include G�del, Escher, Bach (which won the Pulitzer Prize for General Nonfiction in 1980) and Fluid Concepts and Creative Analogies. Emmanuel Sander is Professor of Cognitive and Developmental Psychology at the University of Paris (Saint-Denis), specializing in the study of analogy-making and categorization and their connections to education. Among his previous works is the book Analogy, from the Na�ve to the Creative.
Most helpful customer reviews
248 of 269 people found the following review helpful.
Easy to put down
By David Wineberg
There is obvious passion and great times exhibited by the authors in Surfaces and Essences. They were back and forth between the US and France for years over this. You can feel them sitting around the table, tossing off words, analogs, and examples and probably laughing out loud, till the wine ran out. The boys were having their fun. And it shows. The book is very sprightly. As long as they were at it, they even did a French version, presumably with the examples reversed to show how French differs from English, as opposed to how English differs from French. They kept up the pace and had great enthusiasm for the task, that clearly never lagged. It shows bounce.
Sadly, it also shows overkill. Why give an example or two when you can list fifty or a hundred? Why tell a story when you can tell five of them (all illustrating the same point)? Sometimes they reorder the examples to make a nice pyramid shape, or a sharp upside down pyramid. They worked on phrases until they contained the exact number of letters they needed for the design. Sometimes the examples just run to a whole page, separated by commas. The subheadings have a tendency to be so clever, precious and cute that they give no clue as to the content.
But the real problem is that the book is entirely horizontal, without also being linear. It does not build. It doesn't grow. It just keeps spreading outward. This means you can put the book down any time and pick it up a month later without losing anything. You can open to any page and start reading without having missed anything.
The book's premise is that categorization is effectively the same as analogy. You might think our brains sort everything into neat categories for quick recall. Actually, what we call up are concepts and events for which there is some connection to what is occupying us at the moment - an analogous situation. But after 500 pages of examples of how words and phrases can be extended and compounded and misinterpreted and translated and categorized ad nauseam, I was in despair of ever getting to the payoff.
There isn't one.
It ends with a 30 page "epidialogue" between two women on the phone who've just had a similar nightmare, and they argue about categorization vs analogy, referring to various chapters in the book. Really. It's actually quite cute and comprehensive, and truth be known, if you read that first, you don't need to read the book.
The "argument" for categorization is never strong; there are too many places to question and refute it, and there are too many assumptions I just can't buy and which the authors don't support. Words with capital letters seem to automatically file themselves in their own labeled categories, which presupposes printed language. That can't be right. The etymology of written words further muddies the categorization waters. Words evolve. Meanings evolve. Spellings change. Pronunciations change. It seems to wreak havoc in the ordered world of comprehensive categorizing. And of course, there can't be any such thing as comprehensive categorizing, because it is open ended and infinite, and our brains would have to be the size the universe to accommodate them.
Ultimately it doesn't matter, because analogy beats out categorization and subsumes it. So what was the point of those 500+ pages? And what does analogy over categorization give us? How does it change the world or even just the way we see it? What can we do with this important information? What decisions can we make now that we could not before? No hints are given.
From what I can see they haven't actually discovered anything. But they had fun doing it.
David Wineberg
99 of 113 people found the following review helpful.
Like an omelet full of eggshells
By Ruben Quinones
Reading Surfaces and Essences is like biting an apple and finding half a worm. It's like a pancake eating contest. It is the Phantom Menace of cognitive science literature. What should have been a monumental work about understanding via analogy undermines itself by being too repetitive, too unfocused, too obvious, too silly and too self-referential.
I wanted this book the minute I saw the title because I'm a big fan of well-crafted analogies. I remembered hearing good things about Dr. Hofstadter's book, G�del, Escher, Bach from college roommates who'd read it, which added to my sense of anticipation.
Sadly, other than the prologue and parts of the final chapter, I find very little to recommend here.
The book opens with an exploration of the "zeugma", which is the use of a single word in two different ways in the same sentence. An example of a zeugma from a song I wrote is "I can make you a cup of tea/And you can make me smile." This begins to get at the ability of the human mind to make and break lexical categories in unexpected ways.
Yet starting with the first chapter, Dr. Hofstadter and his co-author, Emmanuel Sander, seem intent on removing everything that was interesting about analogies by taking a particular word or expression and overanalyzing its figurative meanings for a number of pages. The reason this comes across as extremely tedious is that the point has already been made, and it's easily understood. No one who knows what an analogy is needs to ruminate over why a mother board is a little bit like a real mother. Most people who read this book will go dozens of pages at a time without learning anything new.
A number of pages compare airport "hubs" (for airlines) to the hubs of wheels. Who cares?
There's a section on the difference between "and" and "but", as if anyone on Earth could have reached page 109 without understanding that.
They bother to point out that understanding is not actually standing under anything.
One particularly unreadable section uses letter patterns to illustrate how we are reminded of past events. They somehow thought that people wanted to read about how iijjkk-->iijjkd is different from iijjkk-->iijjd and iijjkk-->iijjll. This reminded me of how in high school a classmate thought that the page numbers had some connection with what was happening in the novel. I can't bring myself to care about that.
Chapter 7: Na�ve Analogies and Chapter 8: Analogies that Shook the World were the only two worth writing, though they were not particularly well done. Na�ve Analogies discusses the ways that using physical terms to explain abstract concepts limits our understanding. The best example is that people think of division as splitting something up, thereby making it smaller. However, this is a limiting analogy. If you have four bags of chocolate chips, and you need half of a bag to make one batch of chocolate chip cookies, you can make eight batches of chocolate chip cookies, ending up with a number (8) that is larger than the first two (4 and .5). Thus, 4 � .5 = 8. The last chapter explored analogies in physics, concentrating primarily on Einstein's theories. Unfortunately, the language was so abruptly technical that it seemed like it had been written by a different author.
The Epidialogue has to be the worst possible way to end a book. It's a made-up conversation about two friends discussing categories vs. analogies and referring to parts of this book, Surfaces and Essences, including this very epidialogue. Then one of the characters wakes up, and has a conversation about the crazy conversation it had just dreamed. Then one of the characters wakes up, and it turns out that the second conversation was all a dream, too. It's bad.
Lastly, (analogy alert) the authors' rampant use of clunky, mixed metaphors reminded me of Stephen King's "dandelions" from On Writing. Dandelions are unobtrusive until you notice them on your lawn, and then you really notice them, and they get on your nerves. (For Stephen King, dandelions are adverbs, as in "she replied nonchalantly"). For example, Hofstadter and Sander write: "Once he had glimpsed this analogy, Einstein went way out on a limb, placing all of his chips on it, in a move that to his colleagues seemed crazy." And "The turning point when light quanta at last emerged from the shadows came only in 1923." I'm not sure if the authors are trying to be cute or if they just don't proofread, but this stuff is not good.
It makes me annoyed and write a long negative review.
34 of 36 people found the following review helpful.
"Editor? No, I don't think there's any need for an editor."
By Jim Kornell
Way too long. Were I writing this in the proper spirit, I'd now add six more sentences saying "way too long" in different ways with common English-language tropes and idioms. For me, the argument is unpersuasive: that things mean something according to their relations to other things, and that we describe things by reference to other things -- 'k, fine. No problem. That ALL thinking is this and only this? That, for example, metacognition (which I don't recall being mentioned), musical thinking, spatial thinking, proprioception, perception, all of these are really surface manifestations of analogy-making? The only way I can get to that is if I assume "analogy = representation," which reduces the book to, "the mind works by representing things." Which would have made a six-word book.
Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander PDF
Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander EPub
Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander Doc
Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander iBooks
Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander rtf
Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander Mobipocket
Surfaces and Essences: Analogy as the Fuel and Fire of Thinking, by Douglas Hofstadter, Emmanuel Sander Kindle
